Castration for Rapists

Arguments made for and against castration as an additional form of punishment for rapists and child sex abusers:

UPSC Prelims 2015 Answer Keys

Rape/Sexual Abuse is one of the most heinous crimes imaginable in a modern civilized society . The judiciary came up with a statement for implementing castration as a punishment in rape cases. Castration means either removing testicles (physically) in males or making it dysfunctional by the use of chemicals.

Arguments in Favour of Castration as Punishment:

  • Heinous crimes like child abuses/rapes can be deterred greatly by its enactment.
  • It seems to be the one of the prudent way to deal with growing sexual-crimes in India. As other laws have been proved quite mild.
  • “Impotency” will not only eliminate the sexual desire to a great extent but also it will shame the offenders socially too.
  • It will bring a  fear in the mind of the rapists and seems to be the only solution to stop this inhuman activity.
  • It is an equivalent punishment to rape.
  •  Lack of testes and hence no sexual feelings.
  • Has been proved quite successful in other countries like Russia, Middle-Eastern countries etc.


Arguments against Castration as Punishment:

  • It will not be gender neutral. What about when the offender is a female? By the ongoing practices around the world it is a law for the males only.
  • Non-reversal nature in case if it is physical-castration. Even in Chemical one lots of complications.
  • Offenders might resort to eliminate the victim in order to erase evidence witness .
  • What about Old persons who have already passed the sexual age as abuses are not “penetrative” nature only and in this regard the law seems to be narrow.
  • Family(wife) has to suffer, owing to the fact that divorce is still devoured by the society especially in rural areas it(divorce) is impractical in present times at least.
  • Adverse effect on the rapist and he may turn violent.

“An eye for a eye will make the whole world blind”. What difference does it make to make a convict go through the same pain and hardship? Until and unless our education system changes, sex education is brought up, and the prevailing prejudices is removed regarding a boy and girl communicating since childhood, these inhuman practices cannot be stopped. Also, a physical ill-treatment cannot put an end to a person’s insomniac brain.

Also, borrowing a law or practice which is not indigenous to a place requires lots of work,modification and customisation .

Click here for more articles for UPSC Prelims and MAINS







Print Friendly, PDF & Email

You may also like...

15 Responses

  1. baju muslim says:

    I would like to start a fashion/lifestyle blog. I really like photography, yet I want to up grade my digital camera to a far more professional one. I also wanted to start this blog, so which camera would you suggest me. Excellent small spending budget, so if you could find something that is certainly not as well pricey, I might appreciate it. Thanks a lot!.

  2. For the “letter towards the editor, ” can one send out his/her article to the manager. The guidelines say: “Letters to the editor should just be sent to The Times, and not to other publications. We all do not release open characters or third-party letters. inch.. Does which means that blog posts, as well?.. Thanks a lot..

  3. I want to have a key blogspot web page, but some people I realize have been capable of find my URL using a Google search… is there a way I can prevent this? I may want anyone to be able to realistically find the URL unless of course I give it to them… (Please don’t claim that I switch to another blog. ).. Thanks a lot!.

  4. I would like to copyright the content on my blog (content and images)?? can anyone please guide concerning how can i move abt this?.

  5. Would becoming a paid blogger be considered a good idea to get money?

  6. Can be a good wordpress blog theme for an icanhascheeseburer or failblog duplicate?

  7. Can i shield my blog page content copyright laws without signing up it to copyright departmen? please help?

  8. How can i restore my computer for an earlier time when the “Restore” feature on my computer is definitely not working. I use tried more than a dozen occasions to restore my computer and I keep getting the mistake message “computer could not become restored currently. No adjustments have been made. Try one more date. inch Try another date exactly the same thing happens… All of my personal data files were deleted from my computer and I want to have them back. Have no idea how this happened. Checked the recycle bin and non-e of them were there. It is as though they merely disappeared off my pc. Please help. Thank you!.

  9. besi h beam says:

    Now i am trying to see how can you avoid the content from being eliminated on a youtube video due to copyright laws. I really simply want to see what material do you need so that youtube will not take away the content. Like with music, in the event you use music from like a CD instead of downloading it from like itunes? Can you produce any recommendations?.

  10. I maintain several blogs & forums and allow people to write their comments with them. I examine regularly and remove any kind of swear words, etc . I also inquire commentors not to leave any derogatory conditions on the blogs/forums.. However , having said that, am i actually still legitimately responsible for the content on my blog/forums in the event that they create a defamatory comment or abusive remarks?. Many thanks..

  11. I’m looking for a free or cheap hosting company to move my Joomla website to from my localhost. I want a webhost it doesn’t use Impresionante as its only method of set up? Any suggestions?.

  12. I are new to blog subscriptions and I have always been looking meant for an easy audience that can be nice and structured that enables me watch my sites from my homepage or includes a little scrollbox that is certainly always up on the side of the computer screen. I started to use bloglines however it is really unorganized with all the blog page names arranged on the side. Thanks a ton!.

  13. We updated towards the latest edition, and now it keeps upon coming up with that tab anytime i startup company firefox. What should i do?. I have up-to-date it, there exists a tab saying that i have, this is the problem. It is telling myself all of the brand-new features that this version offers and almost everything..

  14. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! However, how can we communicate?

  15. It seems like the internet is where it’s in. I studied Computer Information and Film/Video at school, but Now i’m not too shabby having a keyboard when it comes to writing interesting stuff. Will anyone know of anyone (aside from Work and Arianna Huffington) who has been able to make a few dollars by running a blog on a site from home?.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *